All-Inclusive vs. Airbnb: Crafting Your Ultimate Getaway in the Dominican Republic

Written By Jessica Vides

When it comes to planning a rejuvenating vacation in the Dominican Republic, travelers are presented with two enticing options: the tried-and-true all-inclusive resorts found in Punta Cana, Puerto Plata and La Romana, or the growing trend of Airbnb rentals offering a blend of privacy and luxury. Both choices promise a relaxing escape, but which is right for you?

In this guide, we'll delve into the pros and cons of each, helping you make an informed decision that aligns perfectly with your vacation preferences. 

All-Inclusive Resorts: The Classic Haven of Relaxation

Falcon’s Resort by Meliá - All Suites Punta Cana

All-inclusive resorts can be the ultimate vacation choice! Think of it as a hotel where you can eat and drink as much as you like, enjoy tons of entertainment, and partake in planned activities – all often right by the ocean. It's the whole package! If you're after a hassle-free vacation with no hidden costs, this might just be your ideal getaway. Families with young kids will appreciate that many of these resorts are designed with children in mind, offering kid-friendly pools and activities. For those planning a romantic escape or a trip with friends, there are also adults-only resorts (I highly recommend these if you're coming without kids).

STRESS-FREE STAYS 

What makes all-inclusive resorts so appealing is a hassle-free vacation experience. Check out popular travel websites like travelzoo.com and cheapcaribbean.com, and you'll often find package deals that cover not just your stay but also your airfare and transportation to the resort. It's a deal that's hard to beat! Pay for everything in one go, then simply count down the days until your travel adventure begins. Once you step foot into the resort, you'll experience top-notch treatment that can make you feel like royalty from arrival to departure. Most resorts also provide access to spa and gym facilities, adding to your relaxation. A week spent at a quality all-inclusive can genuinely work wonders in melting away your everyday stresses.

You may be thinking, what are the downsides of all-inclusive resorts?

VACATION JAIL

The entrance of Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana

Photo Credit: Voyager Guru

Resorts in the Dominican Republic are frequently situated in areas specially designed for tourists, often lacking the rich local culture found outside their walls. On occasion, we've even received advice not to venture beyond the property's borders, creating a sensation like we are in 'vacation jail.'  Of course, if 'vacation jail' comes with the perks of a pool bar and a delicious breakfast buffet, that might be precisely what some travelers desire. Over the years, we've encountered numerous individuals who claim to have visited the Dominican Republic but only set foot in a resort. The question arises: have they truly experienced the full richness of this Caribbean island by confining themselves to the resort's grounds?

Another thing to consider is the number of fellow guests sharing the resort with you. There have been instances when Boscolo and I have enjoyed resorts seemingly all to ourselves, while other times, the place has been so bustling that the breakfast buffet ran out of food, and securing a beach chair felt like a challenge. If you're a social individual who enjoys people-watching and making new friends, the vibrant atmosphere of a busy resort might be right up your alley. 

 

RESORT QUALITY

Another thing to consider is that not all resorts are created equal. We have traveled to resorts in Punta Cana, La Romana and Puerto Plata with high expectations, only to be severely let down. Sometimes it’s the poor shape of the rooms, or the unappealing food options or the severely lacking customer service. When you have been saving and looking forward to a trip for so long, these disappointments can ruin a vacation. We have also stayed at mid-range and high-end resorts that have blown us away and we feel like we are sitting in the lap of luxury. Choosing the right resort for you can be time-consuming, I have spent HOURS on TripAdvisor sifting through the reviews to make a decision on the best place to stay. It is best to do your research before booking. 

 

LUXURY RESORTS IN THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC

You will find the most luxurious resorts with the best customer service in Punta Cana. La Romana also has several recommended ones. Puerto Plata and Samana have budget-friendly, 2-3 star resorts.  Keep in mind that with the budget prices, usually come budget accommodations, quality and service. 

Sanctuary Cap Cana

Photo Credit: Sanctuary Cap Cana

LUXURY RESORTS IN THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC

TIP: Before booking, make sure you shop around for the best rate. Use sites like Cheap Caribbean, Trip Advisor, and Travelzoo for deals.

If you want to work with a travel agent, we recommend using Sharese Gathers Travel Agency. Sharese is an expat who lives in the Dominican Republic and is an expert on all-inclusive getaways on the island.

 

Airbnb Rentals: A Personalized Retreat

Villa in Casa de Campo, La Romana

Photo Credit: Airbnb

Airbnb is an online platform that connects property owners with those seeking places to stay. It offers a wide range of accommodations, from sharing rooms in homes to renting entire villas with full-service staff. This can be especially handy for large group trips. To figure out the cost per person, simply divide the total house price by the number of guests. It can be budget-friendly or comparable to a resort option for spacious and unique stays.

LOCAL CULTURE AND A CUSTOM EXPERIENCES

In contrast to all-inclusive resorts, which are often limited to specific spots, Airbnb rentals are all over the country. This offers a unique chance to immerse yourself in the culture and lifestyle of your chosen destination, all while enjoying the comforts of a home away from home. Beautiful places like Jarabocoa, Las Terrenas, Cabrera, and Barahona in the Dominican Republic provide captivating experiences that aren't dominated by big hotels or resorts but instead offer charming Airbnb accommodations. Here, you can wander through local markets, savor authentic meals at nearby restaurants, and walk the streets to fully embrace the genuine Dominican Republic experience.

Villa Arboleda in El Limon, Samana

Photo Credit: Airbnb

At an Airbnb rental, you're not bound by set dining times or rigid schedules; you can customize your days as you see fit. Whether it's a leisurely breakfast on the terrace, an afternoon siesta by your private pool, or a late-night dip under the stars, your Airbnb becomes a canvas for you to paint your perfect vacation.

 

PRIVACY AND PERSONALIZED EXPERIENCES 

Luxury Airbnb rentals in the Dominican Republic stand out for their offer of a personalized experience, including the option for a private chef and housekeeping services. Imagine waking up to the delightful aroma of a customized breakfast and returning from your adventures to a spotless villa, with a talented chef preparing a dinner tailored to your tastes. Some properties provide a chef as part of the package or as an add-on service for an extra fee. In most cases, you will be responsible for groceries, and the chef transforms them into delicious meals. This is a great way to enjoy local foods and typical Dominican cuisine.  This arrangement offers an almost all-inclusive feel, but it's important to factor in the cost of food and any additional fees.

Villa Salamandra, Las Galeras

Another advantage of an Airbnb stay is the privacy it affords. When you book an Airbnb for your exclusive use, you can bid farewell to early morning chair reservations by the pool and noisy neighbors who won't let you enjoy a peaceful nap. Some travelers cherish the tranquility, while others revel in the social ambiance of a hotel environment. The choice is yours, catering to your desire for either serene solitude or a more socially vibrant vacation experience.

EXTRA RESEARCH EFFORT

The main drawback to renting an Airbnb for your vacation is the planning process. The search for the perfect spot is time-consuming, and many people don’t know where to start. Once you determine the area you want to visit, researching the listings, and reading the descriptions and reviews can be overwhelming. Even if you find the ultimate vacation home, you still may have to research a rental car to get there. Some properties may have a grocery shopping service available for an additional fee or you may have to buy groceries after you arrive. Depending on the kind of traveler you are, this may be where you start looking at resorts OR if you are like me, accept the challenge and dive into the research process to create the vacation of a lifetime.

Is trip planning overwhelming for you? Would you be interested in using travel research consultant services to plan your ultimate getaway to the Dominican Republic?

 

LUXURY AIRBNBS IN THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC

The courtyard of Casa Pantheon in Zona Colonial

When choosing between an all-inclusive resort and an Airbnb rental in the Dominican Republic, remember to align your choice with your vacation goals. Each option offers distinct advantages: resorts for convenience and amenities, and villas for privacy and local immersion. Tailor your decision to your desires to ensure your Caribbean getaway is truly exceptional.

If you are looking for a unique Airbnb experience, don’t miss our post: Top 20 Unique Airbnbs in the Dominican Republic.

Jessica Vides

Jessica Vides has a passion for research and travel. This is a killer combo when it comes to planning a trip. Jessica uses her quest for knowledge and new experiences to create easy-to-digest information to help you plan your next, unforgettable trip! If you aren’t planning to travel, then reading Jessica’s posts will put you in the scene as if you were experiencing it yourself.

Previous

When NOT To Travel to the Dominican Republic
Next

Oviedo Lagoon: A Nature Lover’s Paradise in the Dominican Republic